Chapter 21 · 21.10
Collaborating with someone who uses a different Nextcloud
You're working with another company, a local council or a foundation that has its own Nextcloud. You share a document using their Federated Cloud ID (such as name@cloud.example.com, see Sharing with someone outside your organisation) and the file appears neatly in their Nextcloud. But typing in the same document at the same time, as you would with a colleague, isn't a given. This article explains why, and which way of working always works.
Example: Bakkerij De Korenaar is drawing up a plan for the weekly market together with the local council. The council has its own Nextcloud with a different provider.
Why live editing between two Nextclouds isn't guaranteed
When you collaborate live, all editors are in the same editing session on the same document server. With a regular share within your own WebOké Nextcloud, that's always the case: everyone opens the file through WebOké's Euro-Office. With a federated share, the other person opens the file in their own Nextcloud. That Nextcloud decides which office app opens it: it could be a different Euro-Office or ONLYOFFICE server, or an entirely different program such as Collabora. In that case you're not working in one session, but each in your own session on the same file. Whoever saves last may then overwrite the other person's work.
You can't tell from the outside which office app the other person uses. So assume that live editing through a federated share isn't reliable, unless you've tested it together.
Method 1: a link with editing rights (live collaboration)
If you really want to work in the same document at the same time, let the other person work in your Euro-Office. You do this with a public link or with External shares by email address:
- Open the file's sharing sidebar and create a public link (see Creating a public link (view or edit)), or type the other person's email address under External shares.
- Set the permissions to Can edit.
- Add a password and an expiry date (see Password and expiration date on a link).
- Send the link. The other person opens the document in the browser, enters a name and works in the same session as you. You see each other's cursor and changes straight away (see Working on a document at the same time).
This way the file stays with you in your WebOké Nextcloud, and you keep the version history under your own control (see Version History: restoring an older version).
Method 2: take turns, then compare
Does the file need to be in the other person's Nextcloud, for example because the council requires it? Then agree that only one person edits the file at a time:
- Agree by email or phone who works in the file and when: "I'll work on it until Wednesday, then it's your turn."
- Ask the other person to work with Track changes (see Tracking and accepting changes), so you can see exactly what has changed.
- Has the other person worked in their own copy after all? Put the copy in your Nextcloud and use Compare (see Comparing documents) or Combine (see Combining copies from different reviewers into one document).
Method 3: read only
Does the other person only need to read or comment? Then share with View only and ask for comments by email, or give a link with editing rights and ask them to add comments only (see Commenting and mentioning someone).
Pitfalls
- Two people in two different office apps: one doesn't see the other's changes and whoever saves last wins. If you recognise this (a colleague's text has suddenly disappeared), check the version history (Version History: restoring an older version): the previous version is still there.
- A link with editing rights gets forwarded: anyone with the link can get in. Always use a password and an expiry date, and stop sharing once the work is done.
- Guest name: if the other person doesn't enter a name, they'll appear as Guest in changes and comments. Ask them to enter a name.
Tip: does the other company also use a WebOké Nextcloud? Method 1 is still the safest choice: with a link, everyone is guaranteed to work in the same editing session.
